Soncino English Talmud
Bava Batra
Daf 81a
are corals. Some say Aronim, 'Armonim, Almogim. 'Arinim are ore, 'Armonim are plane trees, Almogim are corals. nbsp; MISHNAH. ONE WHO BUYS TWO TREES IN ANOTHER MAN'S FIELD DOES NOT ACQUIRE OWNERSHIP OF THE GROUND. R. MEIR SAYS: HE DOES ACQUIRE OWNERSHIP OF THE GROUND. [IF THE TREES] GREW LARGE [THE LANDOWNER] MUST NOT CUT DOWN THEIR BRANCHES. WHATEVER GROWS FROM THE STEM IS HIS [THE BUYER'S], AND [WHATEVER GROWS] FROM THE ROOTS [BELONGS] TO THE LANDOWNER. IF [THE TREES] DIED [THE BUYER] HAS NO [CLAIM TO THE] GROUND. ONE WHO BOUGHT THREE [TREES] HAS [IMPLICITLY] ACQUIRED [OWNERSHIP OF THE] GROUND. [IF] THEY GREW LARGE, [THE LANDOWNER] MAY CUT DOWN THEIR BRANCHES. WHATEVER GROWS FROM THE STEM AND FROM THE ROOTS [BELONGS] TO HIM [THE BUYER]. IF [THE TREES] DIED [THE BUYER] HAS [A RIGHT TO THE] POSSESSION OF THE GROUND. GEMARA. We learnt elsewhere: He who buys two trees in another man's [field], has to bring [the bikkurim] but is not to recite [the declaration]. R. Meir Says: He has to bring and recite. Rab Judah said in the name of Samuel: R. Meir subjects to the obligation even him who bought fruit in the market. Whence is this to be inferred? From [the fact that] a superfluous Mishnah has been introduced. For, it should be observed that, [R. Meir] has already taught that he [who bought two trees] has [also] acquired the ground. [Is it not, then,] obvious that he has to bring and to recite? Hence it may be inferred from this [superfluous Mishnah] that R. Meir subjects to the obligation even him who buys fruit in the market. But is it not written: Which thou shalt bring in from thy land? — This is to exclude [the fruit grown] in Foreign Territory. But is it not written: [The choicest first fruit of] thy land [thou shalt bring]? — [This is] to exclude the land of a heathen. But is it not written: The first fruits of [the land] which thou … hast given me? — [This means: The fruits] for which thou hast given me money with which to buy [them]. Raba raised an objection: [It has been taught]: He who buys a tree in another man's [field] brings [the first ripe fruit] but does not recite [the declaration], because he has not acquired ownership of the ground, [these are] the words of R. Meir. — This is, indeed, a refutation. R. Simeon b. Eliakim said to R. Eleazar:
Sefaria
Deuteronomy 26:1 · Deuteronomy 26:10 · Deuteronomy 26:2 · Exodus 23:19 · Deuteronomy 26:10