Soncino English Talmud
Shabbat
Daf 51a
on account of kil'ayim, or the seventh year, or tithes, and they may be removed on the Sabbath. This is indeed a refutation. MISHNAH. IF IT [A POT] WAS NOT COVERED WHILE IT WAS YET DAY, IT MAY NOT BE COVERED AFTER NIGHTFALL. IF IT WAS COVERED BUT BECAME UNCOVERED, IT MAY BE RECOVERED. A CRUSE MAY BE FILLED WITH [COLD] WATER AND PLACED UNDER A PILLOW OR BOLSTER. GEMARA. Rab Judah said in Samuel's name: Cold [water, food, etc. may be hidden.; Said R. Joseph, What does he inform us? We learnt: A CRUSE MAY BE FILLED WITH [COLD] WATER AND PLACED UNDER A PILLOW OR A BOLSTER. Abaye answered him: He tells us much. For if [we learnt] from the Mishnah [alone], I might argue: That applies only to an object which it is not customary to store away, but not to an object which it is customary to store away. Therefore he informs us [that it is not so]. R. Huna said on Rabbi's authority: Cold [water, food, etc.] may not be hidden. But it was taught: Rabbi permitted cold [water, etc.] to be hidden? — There is no difficulty: the one [ruling was given] before he heard it from R. Ishmael son of R. Jose; the other after he heard it [from him]. For Rabbi sat and declared: Cold [water, etc.] may not be hidden. Said R. ishmael son of R. Jose to him, My father permitted cold [water] to be hidden. Then the Elder has already given a ruling, answered he. R. Papa observed: Come and see how much they loved each other! For were R. Jose alive, he would have sat submissively before Rabbi, since R. Ishmael son of R. Jose, who occupied his father's place, sat submissively before Rabbi, yet he [Rabbi] said, Then the Elder has already given a ruling. R. Nahman said to his slave Daru: Put away cold water for me, and bring me water heated by a Gentile cook When R. Ammi heard thereof, he objected. Said R. Joseph: Why should be have objected? He acted in accordance with his teachers, one [act] being according to Rab, and the other according to Samuel. According to Samuel, for Rab Judah said in Samuel's name: Cold [water, etc.] may be hidden. According to Rab, for R. Samuel son of R. Isaac said in Rab's name: Whatever can be eaten in its natural state, raw, is not subject to [the interdict against] the cooking of Gentiles. But he [R. Ammi] held that an important man is different. Our Rabbis taught: Though it was said, One may not store [food] after nightfall even in a substance which does not add heat, yet if one comes to add, he may add. How does he do it? R. Simeon b. Gamaliel said: He may remove the sheets and replace them with blankets, or remove the blankets and replace them with sheets. And thus did R. Simeon b. Gamaliel say: Only the self-same boiler was forbidden; but if it [the food] was emptied from that boiler into another, it is permitted: seeing that he cools it, will he indeed heat it up! If one stored [food] in and covered [it] with a substance that may be handled on the Sabbath, or if he stored [it] in something that may not be handled on the Sabbath, but covered [it] with something that may be handled on the Sabbath, he may remove [the covering] and replace it. If one stored [food] in and covered [it] with a substance that may not be handled on the Sabbath, or if he stored (it] in something that may be handled on the Sabbath, but covered it with something that may not be handled on the Sabbath, provided it was partly uncovered, he may take it [out] and replace [it]; but if not,
Sefaria
Mesoret HaShas