Parallel Talmud
Yevamot — Daf 26b
Babylonian Talmud (Gemara) · Soncino English Talmud
חמשה נמי למיתה דתרי לא חיישינן
אמר רבא בר רב הונא אמר רב שלש אחיות יבמות שנפלו לפני שני אחין יבמין זה חולץ לאחת וזה חולץ לאחת ואמצעית צריכה חליצה משניהם
אמר ליה רבה מדקאמרת אמצעית צריכה חליצה משניהם קסברת יש זיקה והויא לה חליצה פסולה וחליצה פסולה צריך לחזור על כל האחין
אי הכי קמייתא נמי
אי דנפול בבת אחת הכי נמי לא צריכא דנפול בזו אחר זו
נפלה חדא חלץ לה ראובן נפלה אידך חלץ לה שמעון
נפלה אידך חלץ לה האי מפקע זיקתו חלץ לה האי מפקע זיקתו
והאמר רב אין זיקה לדברי האומר יש זיקה קאמר
ושמואל אמר אחד חולץ לכולן מכדי שמעינן ליה לשמואל דאמר חליצה מעליא בעינן דאמר שמואל
the same applies to five brothers also! -The possibility that two might die need not be taken into consideration. Rabbah son of R. Huna said in the name of Rab: If three sisters who are sisters-in-law fell to the lot of two brothers who are their brothers-in-law, one of the brothers participates in her halizah with one, and the other brother participates in the halizah with the other, but the third, requires halizah from both. Said Rabbah to him: Since you say that the third widow requires submission to halizah by both brothers, you must be holding the opinion that a Ievirate bond exists and that the halizah is of an impaired character, and that as an impaired halizah it must go the round of all the brothers; but if so, [the same should apply to] the first [two sisters] also! — If they had become subject [to the levirs] at the same time the law would indeed have been so; [the statement of our Mishnah, however,] was required only in the case where they become subject [to the Ievirs] one after another. When the first sister became subject to the obligation of the levirate marriage. Reuben participated in her halizah; when the second came Under the obligation. Simeon participated in her halizah; when the third came under the obligation. if the one brother participated in her halizah he removed his own levirate bond, and when the other participated in the halizah he likewise removed his own levirate bond. But, surely. Rab said that no levirate bond exists! — This statement he made in accordance with the opinion of him who maintains that a levirate bond does exist. Samuel, however, stated that one brother participates in the halizah with all of them. But consider: We have heard Samuel say that a proper halizah is required for Samuel said: